Bitcoin (BTC) Lose to US Treasury Securities for Almost 10% in 12 Months – The End of Narrative of "Value Reserve"?


Discover exactly where Smart Money is moving capital in real-time. By registering on our platform, you unlock the complete ExpertFX ecosystem: high-precision consensus algorithms, millimetric technical data, and elite educational guides on risk and emotional management. Secure your spot in the free environment before the VIP transition.
By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use of Use and Privacy Policy
While the crypto media celebrates every little bitcoin repeat and analysts predict parabolic rallyes, cold and hard data tell a very different and worrying story. A new analysis reveals that, in the last 12 months, the Bitcoin (BTC) performed less than the US Treasury Securities (Treasuries) by almost 10%.
By Igor Pereira, Financial Market Analyst, Junior Member WallStreet NYSE
This is the elephant in the room that nobody wants to discuss: the most risky and volatile asset on the planet is losing to the asset considered "risk-free".
1. The Shame Chart: BTC vs. USTs
The chart below illustrates Bitcoin's relative total return compared to a US Treasury Securities Index (Bloomberg US Treasure Total Return Index) over the past year.
The Red Line: It represents relative performance. A downward line means the BTC is losing to the Treasures.
The Result: Since the end of 2024, the line has fallen consistently, now reaching a subperformance of almost -10%.
2. What Does It Really Mean?
This destroys several central Bitcoin narratives in this cycle:
Narrative of "Value Reserve": If an asset loses value in relation to "safe" money (government bonds) for a period of one year, it failed in its primary value reserve function.
"Hedge Against Inflation/Debasement" narrative: In a year marked by US tax concerns and explosive debt (which should boost anti-fiat assets), the BTC failed to even keep track of the debt bonds itself that it supposedly protects against.
Risk vs. Return: The investor who assumed the extreme risk, volatility and regulatory uncertainty of Bitcoin was rewarded with a return worse than the one who just bought government bonds and went to sleep. The BTC risk premium has become negative.
3. The Contrast with Gold
It is impossible not to compare this performance with that of Gold (XAU/USD). In the same period, gold reached nominal and real historical maxims, overcoming massively both Bitcoin and Treasures. Gold fulfilled its role as refuge and hedge; Bitcoin did not.
Conclusion of Igor Pereira: The Market Is Talking
The institutional Smart Money looks at this data. They don't buy narratives; they buy risk-adjusted returns. The fact that BTC is losing to Treasures is a clear sign that in the current macro environment (high interest, uncertainty), Bitcoin is being treated as a speculative risk asset (risk-on)And not like a safe harbor.
For the members of ExpertFX School, this reinforces our thesis: in times of real uncertainty and systemic danger, capital flees to proven refuge (Gold and Titles), not to digital speculation. Bitcoin still has its place as a tactical asset, but the idea that it replaced gold or securities as a central value reserve was for the time being refuted by the market itself.
Want to take your analysis to the institutional level?
This analysis is just the tip of the iceberg. ExpertFX School Premium Members Receive daily insights, premium analysis in-depth and Direct access to our closed group on Telegram, where we discuss the market in real time.
Don't operate on noise. Operate based on intelligence.
Access your dashboard and become Premium now:https://expertfxschool.com/dashboard