Miners call for help to challenge the domain of China's rare land


Discover exactly where Smart Money is moving capital in real-time. By registering on our platform, you unlock the complete ExpertFX ecosystem: high-precision consensus algorithms, millimetric technical data, and elite educational guides on risk and emotional management. Secure your spot in the free environment before the VIP transition.
By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use of Use and Privacy Policy
Government support for rare earths projects will remain necessary for years as Western countries work to counter Chinaâs long-standing dominance of the sector, industry leaders said at the AFR Mining Summit in Perth last week.
There has been growing debate over state intervention in critical minerals markets, but speakers agreed rare earths remain a special case because of decades of market distortion driven by Chinese supply and pricing influence.
âThe rare earths market has been a distorted market for decades, and so the government intervention that we have seen by the US, Japanese and Australian governments actually is more about correcting that dysfunction,â outgoing Lynas Rare Earths (ASX: LYC) CEO and newly appointed Minerals Council of Australia chair Amanda Lacaze said. âGovernment participation in addressing this dysfunction is ultimately good for the market.â
The comments highlight how governments are increasingly shaping critical minerals supply chains as Western nations seek to build alternative sources of strategic materials used in electric vehicles, defence systems and advanced manufacturing.
Floor prices a game changer
Arafura Rare Earths (ASX: ARU) managing director Darryl Cuzzubbo credited the US governmentâs investment in MP Materials (NYSE: MP) and the introduction of a rare earths floor price with accelerating the sectorâs development outside China.
âBut theyâre kind of learning as they go, so itâs a bit of a wild ride,â he said. âWithout that US leadership, Iâm not sure weâd be in the sort of fast-paced transition that we are in.â
Bank of America head of natural resources equity research Australia Kate McCutcheon said floor prices had removed Chinaâs incentive to flood the market and drive down prices.
âWhen we have really big markets like steel or iron, we can use tools like tariffs, which is what weâve seen in the US and Europe, to decouple that supply chain,â she said.
âWhereas, in smaller markets like rare earths, what weâve seen is money really helps that problem, and weâve seen those floor prices have actually forced that China price in line with the ex-China price for rare earths.
âSo, in the fullness of time, will government support be needed? Itâs here for the foreseeable future.â
BlackRock portfolio manager Olivia Markham said government involvement extended beyond direct funding to permitting, infrastructure and maintaining stable fiscal regimes.
âGovernments are getting much more involved in this entire space,â she said.
The risk
Rowena Smith, CEO of Australian Strategic Materials (ASX: ASM), currently subject to a $300 million takeover by Energy Fuels (TSX: EFR), that government support should be reserved for projects capable of standing on their own commercially.
âYou donât want to subsidize a project thatâs never going to be economic to operate,â she said.
Cuzzubbo agreed intervention was needed to address market failures but warned against creating permanent support mechanisms that distort competition.
Last month, Arafura approved development of its $1.9 billion Nolans rare earths project in the Northern Territory, backed by financing from nine lenders across five countries, most of them government-backed institutions.
âCan you imagine a world where everyone gets a floor price? That is not a functioning market,â Cuzzubbo said. âIf everyone gets a floor price, then uneconomic projects will get up.
âYou will then flood the market, youâll push down real prices, and governmentâs picking up the tab, so the floor price was absolutely essential to circumvent China, but it is not the long-term answer.â
The debate underscores a broader challenge facing governments and industry alike: supporting the emergence of independent rare earths supply chains without creating permanent market distortions. As new projects move toward production, participants increasingly see transparent and liquid pricing mechanisms as the eventual path to a self-sustaining market.
Cuzzubbo and Smith both endorsed the development of independent pricing indices, although they said greater trading volumes would be required to make them credible. In the meantime, Smith argued temporary measures such as floor prices remain necessary to support a growing but still fragile industry.
âWe need some sort of scaffold in the interim, and I think floor prices have played an important role,â she said. âWeâve got to be pragmatic about how high this floor price is.
âAgain, this comes back to we canât be supporting and subsidizing projects that are not inherently economic as we establish this emerging alternate supply chain, but for us, weâre excited because that market, whilst itâs small, is growing.â