Jump to content

Gold is worth about 20% of the global stock market, far from the historical peaks of 85% to 90%: what the graph suggests about the metal cycle

Voice

ExpertFX Podcast - No time to read? Let me read it for you. Press Play!

The ratio between the gold value above the ground and the capitalization of the world's purses has risen, but it is still close to the historical minimum compared to the big cycles. I read the chart, the eight arguments of the thesis and three caveats that every trader should have.

The chart, signed by Azuria Capital, measures the value of all gold already extracted as a percentage of the value of the world's shares, in a series starting in 1901. The reading that analysts do is that metal is still "at the beginning of the cycle": the reason is around 20% at the last point, while in the three major peaks of the last century it has reached something between 85% and 90%. The data comes from the set DMS (UBS/Credit Suisse), the World Bank and the World Federation of Scholarships.

image.png

Two simple accounts help scale. Faced with the minimum of 1999 and 2000, the current ratio is about five times. Faced with peaks of 85% to 90%, it is still a fraction: to go back there, the value of gold in relation to shares would need to grow more than four times. It's an illustrative comparison, not a prediction, but it shows the size of the distance.

The eight arguments of the thesis, and how I assess them

ArgumentMy evaluation
Global debt in recordHigh debt creates permanent incentive to real low interest or inflation. In practice, today high interest rates weigh against metal.
Inflation as a path of less resistanceIt makes sense: inflation is still far from controlled, and the PCE of August, in 3.8%, shows this.
Gold still below 30% of central bank assetsIt explains why official purchases remain strong, as seen in China, which expands reserves every month.
Deglobalisation favours neutral assetsGold has no counterparty risk, and that's worth more in a fragmented world.
60/40 wallets looking for alternativesWhen stocks and bonds fall together, gold enters as the third leg of the wallet.
Unsustainable tax deficitsThe 30-year auction today, the 5.618%, the highest yield since 2000, is a reminder of the prize that the market has already charged.
Stable world productionThe offer does not respond quickly to the price, which amplifies demand movements.
Lack of new discoveriesIt limits future supply and supports the price in the long term.

Three caveats I make

1. Reason rises in two ways.Looking at the peaks, notice that they coincide with crises: wars, the Great Depression and the stagflation of the 1970s. In several of these moments, reason went off not only because the gold went up, but because the stock fell too much. That is, a high peak in reason may be a sign of trouble in purses, not just gold strength.

2. Today's 20% already equals the previous top.The last point is slightly above the peak of 2011 and 2012, when gold made the top of the past cycle. So the "beginning of the cycle" thesis depends on the reason going beyond that roof, and not just being low in relation to the war and inflation of the 1970s.

3. Long cycle is not a trigger.A 125-year-old series shows a trend, but it says nothing about the coming weeks. In September, for example, gold fell with interest and dollar up, even with all these arguments present.

How I use it in XAU/USD

I use the graph as a context of conviction, not as a sign of operation. He tells me that, in the long run, the wind is favorable to metal and that strong falls tend to find structural buyers, such as central banks. In the short term, I keep looking at what it always says: the 10-year yield, the dollar and inflation data, with the CPI of October 14th as the next test.

My conclusion: the thesis that gold is at the beginning of the cycle has solid arguments, but the graph asks for humility, because what it shows for sure is that metal is far from the euphoria of the past, and not that euphoria will return. Those who operate must respect the short-term risk and let the long-term thesis work for small and well-protected positions.

Igor Pereira

Financial market analyst and member Junior WallStreet NYSE

Premium ExpertFX:long thesis is context, and entry is level. In the Premium area you will find the analyses with detailed technical levels of gold and the institutional panel of orders to see where the big players are positioned.

Latest comments

Join the conversation

You can article now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to article with your account.
Note: Your article will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Terminal Visitor
What is your take on this move?

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...


  • ACCESS A MARKET

    Discover exactly where Smart Money is moving capital in real-time. By registering on our platform, you unlock the complete ExpertFX ecosystem: high-precision consensus algorithms, millimetric technical data, and elite educational guides on risk and emotional management. Secure your spot in the free environment before the VIP transition.

Live Global Sessions
Real-time NYSE Data Feed
Enjoying ExpertFX? 📈
Your review helps our community grow. Rate the app in seconds.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use of Use and Privacy Policy

×
×
  • Create New...