How Gold Supercharges Portfolio Diversification (And How Much You Should Own)

[Ben Graham]

 For thousands of years, gold has been a treasured asset. Gold is not only a time-honored symbol of wealth, it is a reliable store of value and wealth building tool. Today, this ancient currency’s role in modern portfolios is becoming more important than ever. As you know, global uncertainty and shifting economic tides have put gold back in the spotlight—as the precious metal has surged 40% higher since the start of the year setting new record highs.  

A new study by the D. E. Shaw group, Worth Its Weight? Assessing Gold’s Portfolio Utility offers a refreshingly honest look at gold’s strengths, and the key reasons why it is relevant today, even as global markets evolve. Here’s what they found.  

Unlike other paper assets like stocks or bonds, gold doesn’t produce income. Instead, gold serves as a store of value—a non-productive store of value (NPSOV)—that people turn to in times of uncertainty. When inflation rises, countries go to war, governments take on staggering amounts of debt, or the U.S. dollar’s future as a reserve currency comes into question, gold looks appealing as a safe haven. 

Gold and Other Assets: The Correlation Story 

One of gold’s biggest benefits is how it stands apart from other financial investments. Over the last five decades, gold’s correlation with U.S. stocks has averaged just 0.01—meaning stock and gold prices usually don’t move together. This lack of significant overlap means gold reduces your portfolio risk when the stock market sinks. 

Gold’s relationship to bonds has been slightly more positive (correlation of 0.10), but is still low enough to provide diversification. Its connection to inflation is modest but positive (averaging 0.13 since 2004). What you’re left with is an asset that stands a little apart—neither firmly with stocks, nor bonds, nor inflation, but with enough separation to matter. 

What really drives gold’s portfolio benefits is how stocks and bonds interact with each other. Traditionally, investors have relied on these assets moving in opposite directions. But since 2021, their correlation has flipped positive, meaning they sometimes lose value together. (You may remember the first four months of 2022, when the S&P 500 Index dropped by 12.9%, while the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index fell by 9.5%. Ouch).  

When this happens, assets like gold that don’t trade in tandem with stocks or bonds become much more valuable to help preserve and protect your wealth.  

Portfolio Utility: Optimization in Action 

So, how should investors use gold? The study runs thought experiments using an optimizer, balancing return assumptions, volatility, stock-bond correlations, and the risk of market crashes. Even with the most basic assumptions—modest returns and no income—the optimizer finds value in holding gold. Crucially, when considering positive stock-bond correlations and potential market crashes, gold’s utility rises dramatically. The optimizer might allocate a larger portion of the portfolio to gold if these scenarios loom larger.  

How Much Gold Should You Own?  

The D. E. Shaw group recommends that investors may want to allocate as much as 9% of their portfolios to gold, especially in environments where stocks and bonds are positively correlated or when risks such as market crashes and inflation spikes are heightened to protect overall wealth and reduce portfolio risk.

Other studies have revealed that larger gold allocations can offer even greater portfolio protection and wealth building opportunities for investors.

A groundbreaking study by Ibbotson and Associates found that allocating 15% of a portfolio to gold enhances overall stability across different market cycles by benefiting from gold’s negative correlation with equities.

Their conclusion aligns with CPM Group’s analysis, which, based on data since 1968, recommends increasing gold exposure to 25% during extended periods of economic downturn. Meanwhile, silver’s unique dual role as both a monetary metal and an industrial commodity introduces distinctive volatility: although it tends to lag behind gold in early risk-off phases, its higher sensitivity to market movements often results in higher gains during the later stages of a bull market.

Growing interest in lifecycle allocation strategies highlights tailored approaches to precious metals investments. For investors younger than 40, David Morgan recommends dedicating 10-20% of the portfolio to precious metals, favoring a mix weighted 70% toward silver and 30% toward gold to capitalize on silver’s stronger growth prospects during wealth-building years. After retirement, this allocation flips—allocating 70% to gold and 30% to silver—to emphasize wealth preservation, supported by gold’s lower correlation (0.22) to the S&P 500 compared to silver’s higher correlation (0.41).  

On the institutional side, BlackRock’s 2025 Portfolio Construction Report introduced a Permanent Gold Allocation framework calling for 12-18% gold exposure for pension funds, recognizing gold’s reduced annualized volatility (18%) relative to long-term Treasury bonds (24%). This reflects a shift in mindset viewing gold as a foundational institutional asset rather than just a speculative investment. 

The Bottom Line 

Gold’s independence from major cycles, potential to perform in market crashes, and low correlation to other assets combine to offer real diversification in times of uncertainty. 

Whether the future holds more inflation, geopolitical strife, or unpredictable stock-bond relationships, gold offers utility that can’t be ignored. The D. E. Shaw group’s research reminds investors to focus on the numbers, not the myths, and understanding how assets really behave over time. 

The post How Gold Supercharges Portfolio Diversification (And How Much You Should Own) appeared first on Blanchard and Company.